If you are going to go with a single format type of drive then i would recomend the - format, simply because this has far out sold the + format.There is no one drive that is 100 % a winner, at the end of the day, everyone here has spoken of there own choice of drive, the pioneer is a very good and popular drive, but it all comes down to what you want to do with it, i personaly own the toshiba, my first choice was actualy the sony, but they couldnt deleaver, so i went for the toshiba simply because of its CD protections capability. If you want a drive that will do DVD and copy CD games then the tosh is the drive to go for, as it will cut through most protections(exept audio) with ease and also burn perfect copies of most protections, the sony and the pioneer struggle with this.