What compression level is acceptable?

I'm a newbie using DVDShrink. When shrinking parts of the menus, extras, etc. to allow for a higher compression level for the main movie, how do you know when enough is enough? Obviously uncompressed or a high compression level is best, but will a compression level of 70% look bad? Will a compression level of 80% look much better than 70%, or will you not really be able to visually see the difference? As I said, I'm new to this and I can't seem to find the answer anywhere alse. I don't want to waste a bunch of disks to find out, so I'm relying on your past experience! Thank you! GREAT forum!
 

nwg

Member
There is too many variables. The original bitrate is the most important. A high bitrate will allows more compression and still get excellent results. Low bitrate will not get good results. I tend to stick with 75% and above.

I have started to take stuff out with DVD stripper to make sure the compression is less as posssible.

I have done Fellowship of the Ring Extended Edition to one disc from two disc and kept the DD 5.1 sound. I compressed it by 60% (40% on Shrink's scale). It still looked excellent on my 28" widescreen TV. The film was three and a half hours long.

I did the same with The Two Towers EE and it looked a lot worse as it was also 10 minutes longer than FOTR. I used another bit of software for that.

The best way to found out is to use a DVD RW disc and experiment at different levels of compresion. Always use deep analysis when compressing more than 5%.
 
Top