NFL'S greatest RB of all time

NFL'S greatest RB of all time?

  • Jim Brown

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • Walter Payton

    Votes: 1 20.0%
  • Barry Sanders

    Votes: 2 40.0%
  • Emmit Smith

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Eric Dickerson

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Gale Sayers

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Tony Dorsett

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Marshall Faulk

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Marcus Allen

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • O.J Simpson

    Votes: 1 20.0%

  • Total voters
    5
S

Shoebedobedoo

Guest
As the NFL 2002-2003 season approaches, who do you consider the greatest running back of all time? Sorry in advance if I didn't nominate your favorite RB ;)

Shoebedobedoo:cool:
 
I have to go with Jim Brown on this one. There was an ESPN special on him and all I can say is, "Holy Sh!t!" Jim Brown would make it in today's NFL and absolutely DOMINATE.

Strype
 
I voted for Barry Sanders. He would have shattered the all-time rushing record if he had not retired.
He had some incredible runs.
Next would be Payton then Brown.
 
S

Shoebedobedoo

Guest
Strype,
Just remember that when Jim Brown played, men in those days played both ways (offense& defense). Also in Jim Brown's days, defenses didn't substitute like they did in the 80's, 90's, to present day. If Jim Brown were to play today in the NFL, I'm not convinced he would have averaged 100 yards a game.
 
I know they played both ways. The offense has a tremendous advantage over the defense with today's rules. Jim Brown is certainly better than Dillon, George, Anderson (When he was healthy), Terrel Davis and any other powerback in the NFL today. Have you seen those plays that he flatout ran the f*** over some of those HOF defensive players? I don't know about him catching the ball out of the backfield though. So it would be hard to compare him to Faulk. Although Faulk doesn't have anywhere near the power that Brown had. But I positively believe Brown could dominate in today's NFL.

I am of the opinion that if Barry Sanders got the touches inside the 5 yd line like the rest of the NFL backs, he wouldn't have lasted long enough to get that record.

Strype
 
S

Shoebedobedoo

Guest
Strype,
Jim Brown sure could knock over defensive players like bowling pins :D If I needed 3 yards, I would definatly pick Jim Brown to run the football, and if he were injured, then I would have to give the ball to either Emmit Smith or Marcus Allen ;) If I needed a quick score from a long distance, I definatly would give the ball to Barry Sanders and if he were injured, I would give the ball to Eric Dickerson. Walter Payton in his prime could knock defensive players on their booty too :D

Shoebedobedoo:cool:
 
Too bad Bo got injured. I think he would have been on that list as well. Man, what a RB he coulda been!

Definitely agree with your take in the above post. :D

Strype
 
S

Shoebedobedoo

Guest
O.J got away with murder, but we can't take away what he accomplished in the NFL

joripe,
O.J did get away with (my opinion), but we can't take away what he accomplished on the football field. O.J is definatly paying the price for what he "did" now (hehe).

Shoebedobedoo:cool:
 
Top